Reviews

What a great place we found today. The FD special was awesome. Roast beef w/ cheese, shrooms & sweet onions, yum. The Blackberry Whiskey & Blackberry Lemonade were delicious.

Kecia Cortrecht via google.com - Jun 17, 2019

Dinner

Great food nice outside patio or can eat inside. Patio is nice with a great view of the brewery across the street Our waitress was very nice and attentive also ... read more

SaraDCarter via tripadvisor.com - Jun 13, 2019

Great food.

Christine Meyer via google.com - Jun 9, 2019

Bloody mary was great and i have ate lunch here many times always good...its a tourist town so its a littke pricey but building is super cool ... read more

Chad Vann via google.com - Jun 2, 2019

This was our first time . The food was delicious, the service was great and a relaxing atmosphere. We will definitely be back.

Amanda Salazar via google.com - May 25, 2019

Absolutely the best Seafood Platter I've ever eaten! Our waitress Valerie W was awesome & very informative. We will be back!!

Ann Stock via google.com - May 22, 2019

Worlds best Mac and cheese

Food is so fantastic we went there twice in one day! We had a male server named Jody we think and a gal named Cassidy at night. Both great. Hosts at door bad but servers made up for it. Chef came to our table which...More ... read more

Jane J via tripadvisor.com - May 19, 2019

Beautifully restored, good service, great food! I highly recommend checking out this restaurant. Th

Beautifully restored, good service, great food! I highly recommend checking out this restaurant. The menu is limited, but proportions are huge! I actually split a meal with my sister, and it was perfect! Which helps with the price too! This was our favorite restaurant of our trip to Hermann!

Jamie Cates via facebook.com - May 15, 2019

My Mom, sister and I came for our last dinner in town and it was the best choice! We are foodies and this place is filled with history and flavorful food. Our waitress was on point. We all ordered seafood platters with salads and baked potato. One of the platters included the lobster Mac and Cheese, it was out of this world! It's a m ... read more

Ariane Briscoe via google.com - May 14, 2019

Food and service

The food was fantastic, and our server Cassidy B. was awesome. Can't think one thing we didn't love about Tin Mill.

keleka8080 via tripadvisor.com - May 12, 2019

Good food but crowded

My wife and I enjoyed the food and beer at the Tin Mill Steak House. We both had the Rib Eye and thought it delicious. But like much of Herman, if you go on a busy Saturday night be ready for the crowd.

NeocroseAlexander via tripadvisor.com - May 12, 2019

Dinner

Six of us for dinner at 7:30 on Saturday. Waited approximately 12 minutes at the bar for our table. Great old fashioned and wine. Dinner was tasty. Men had well cooked steaks. Salads and potatoes were excellent. Ladies enjoyed the risotto app, French onion soup,...More ... read more

sheilab402 via tripadvisor.com - May 6, 2019

Good food and drinks ... read more

Ron Kramer via google.com - May 6, 2019

Amazing

Great atmosphere, friendly staff. Staff was willing to go out of their way to meet out needs and make our visit a pleasant one. The bourbon chicken was cooked beautifully. I highly recommend stopping by.

Catkit42 via tripadvisor.com - May 5, 2019

Need a fork truck to lift me from the table!

We celebrated our 5th wedding anniversary at the Tin Mill. The staff were concerned they were understaffed. However, we didn't wait long and the customer service was excellent. The food was amazing. We ordered the 12oz Ribeye and baked potato. Literally needed a fork truck...More ... read more

Jennifer C via tripadvisor.com - Apr 30, 2019

Steaks are amazing! Food is delicious ... read more

Cammie Smith via google.com - Apr 28, 2019

Had an amazing experience with my crew as always. We drive through here all the time for our lunch

Had an amazing experience with my crew as always. We drive through here all the time for our lunch break every time we are in the area. Our server and bar tender was absolutely awesome and he made us some amazing drinks and his suggestions for food turned out amazing.

Shawna Stinson via facebook.com - Apr 25, 2019

Excellent food and service. Best lobster Mac I have had.

Shelly Jean via facebook.com - Apr 22, 2019

Interesting & historic mill that is now a Restaurant. The filet was tender and cooked as requested. Baked potato was disappointing, as it had obviously been cooked for awhile & warmed up poorly at that (still cold on inside). Waitress was nice, but forgot about us & we had to go find her. It is a big area, but we were sitting outside ... read more

Mary Bradford via google.com - Apr 22, 2019

Showed up with 17 people and without ...

Showed up with 17 people and without a reservation, and the Tin Mill team handled us with ease. The lunch menu looked very affordable (same menu for both), but was unavailable for dinner. The dinner entrees were a higher price point than we were expecting, but all turned out to be delicious.

Trevor M. via yelp.com - Apr 21, 2019

Good food a little pricey but over all good people work there.

William Decker via google.com - Apr 14, 2019

Good food in a neat old barn turned restaurant

We had reservations, which are highly recommended. Seated immediately, nice that they saved our tables and made others wait due to reservations. Other places will seat some anyway and cause delays on reservations. I couldn't decide between two wines and the server even offered to...More ... read more

jfs6 via tripadvisor.com - Apr 8, 2019

Great food and beer!

Marny Mendenhall via google.com - Apr 6, 2019

Had a great birthday dinner for my wife great food and service !!!

Joe Evola via google.com - Apr 2, 2019

Great appetizers

Excellent appetizers at the bar. Had the opportunity to speak with the head Chef and he gave us great insight into the quality and originality of the menu. The beer was pretty good as well. The doppelboch was very tasty. Highly recommend. I enjoyed a...More ... read more

Liz W via tripadvisor.com - Mar 31, 2019

Incredible experience! Kind hearted chef even visited our table!! Beautiful fresh food crafted with care, stunning environment & good drink.

Kandy Giles via google.com - Mar 30, 2019

Risotto bite and the bratwurst with beer cheese. Risotto bites was good but the worst and beer cheese was awesome. Surprisingly the prices wasnt bad for lunch menu. Prices on the dinner was a bit higher but I'm sure those items would be just as great. Need to go back to try them. Only complaint was something was off with mountain dew ... read more

Patrick Freeman via google.com - Mar 25, 2019

Great food

We were in Hermann for our anniversary, decided to go to The Mill the food was so good!! The portion was huge. The building was so neat. I had the shrimp platter my husband had the pork ribeye. The chef came out beforehand. The waiter...More ... read more

AngieM_18LPN via tripadvisor.com - Mar 24, 2019

Wonderful ... read more

Denise Jordan via google.com - Mar 24, 2019

Excellent eclectic food and beverages ... read more

Liz Whelan via google.com - Mar 24, 2019

Great food and great setvice ... read more

Randy Moffett via google.com - Mar 22, 2019

We had an amazingly delicious dinner last night at Tin Mill Steakhouse. I had the fillet steak which was so tender it could have been cut with a fork. Awesome flavor! My significants other had the salmon & said it was the best he ever had. The service and atmosphere were perfect for my birthday dinner. We will certainly be back soo ... read more

Diann Sethaler via google.com - Mar 21, 2019

Their BLT is absolutely amazing and they also have a Blackberry Whiskey that is impressively good. I can't handle whiskey well but this one is smooth and super enjoyable ... read more

Brittany Branson via google.com - Mar 9, 2019

DELICIOUS!!!

Randall Lewis via google.com - Mar 3, 2019

Food, service and atmosphere A+

We had the 12 oz sirloin steak. The steak was seasoned and cooked to perfection. Our server helped with wine selection, letting me sample two different red wines before ordering.

ewingp via tripadvisor.com - Feb 27, 2019

Service was excellent. Atmosphere was awesome. We had the prime rib on Monday which was the best I have ever had anywhere. Also the pork ribeye which was amazing. Would absolutely be a do over.

Shane Johnson via google.com - Feb 26, 2019

Great date dinner

Service was excellent. Atmosphere was awesome. We had the prime rib on Monday which was the best I have ever had anywhere. Also the pork ribeye which was amazing. Would absolutely be a do over.

KDandVA via tripadvisor.com - Feb 26, 2019

Thanks Dawn, my brother and I had an awesome hike and just picked a great place to go. Definitely need to come back when we can. High five! ✋😁 ... read more

Joshua R Adams via google.com - Feb 24, 2019

Lovely place to eat. The steaks were cooked perfect! we will definitely be back.

Kevin-and Penny Thomas via facebook.com - Feb 24, 2019

We celebrated our wedding anniversary there last night and it was WONDERFUL! Great food, great ser

We celebrated our wedding anniversary there last night and it was WONDERFUL! Great food, great server and beautiful atmosphere. Thank you!

Carole Davies Brown Behrer via facebook.com - Feb 19, 2019

The food is great and the building is fascinating.

Jan Jett via google.com - Feb 17, 2019

Excellent restaurant very friendly staff amazing food very beautiful aesthetic all in all a great place to visit ... read more

justin wallace via google.com - Feb 15, 2019

We had another great dinner. The food and service was excellent. Good job Eric and staff.

Kathy Durham via facebook.com - Feb 15, 2019

Awesome place eat ... read more

Candy Butler via google.com - Feb 6, 2019

Good food and music. Most restaurants have crappy music. I came in for lunch and it was great. Frie

Good food and music. Most restaurants have crappy music. I came in for lunch and it was great. Friendly staff. Hermann is awesome. Walk up to the wursthaus to take some German sausage and cheese home with you :) ... read more

Tab Lynn via facebook.com - Feb 3, 2019

Had some delicious food and drinks for dinner. Seafood platter was so good, best lobster mac & cheese ever! Loved their very own craft beers. Highly recommend for dinner or lunch while visiting Hermann! Thanks to our server Betty for wonderful service!

Christine Toettcher via google.com - Feb 3, 2019

Very good food.

Dale Hunter via google.com - Jan 30, 2019

Good service an good atmosphere

Good service an good atmosphere ... read more

Greg Burgess via facebook.com - Jan 19, 2019

quaint very good food and good service ... read more

Mary Summers via google.com - Jan 16, 2019

Great food, great service, great atmosphere!

Ray Tribe via google.com - Jan 12, 2019

Went twice in 2 days!

They make their own butter! The baked ravioli was so good and the seafood gumbo was delicious. The building is full of history and I got a full tour of the place and the run down of its history.

native_irish via tripadvisor.com - Jan 5, 2019

I love the Tin Mill. Great food. Their midnight whistle is one of my all time favorite beers.

Casey Duello via google.com - Dec 24, 2018

👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻Top notch restaurant!!!

👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻 Top notch restaurant!!!

Eric Nichols via facebook.com - Dec 21, 2018

Great management and wait staff. Very friendly and courteous!

My husband and I celebrated our anniversary here two years in a row. We love the atmosphere, the food, the wine. It's all very cozy!

joybird62 via tripadvisor.com - Dec 17, 2018

Yummy

We had dinner here Saturday the 15th. This was our second trip in 9 months. Food was off the charts. Pork rib eye is amazing. Sirloin spot on. Shelia was our server. She did an excellent job. If you have been disappointed in the past....More ... read more

lagnafer via tripadvisor.com - Dec 16, 2018

Great Food

Had one of the best steaks and waitress when we went for dinner. This was the second time we went there, this was the best one.

jhammerschmidt2018 via tripadvisor.com - Dec 12, 2018

Sunday dinner

Sunday dinner with hubby. Excellent food & great service! The seafood platter is BIG and Tasty. The nice staff gave wonderful service and the rustic atmosphere made this a great experience!

Rebecca H via tripadvisor.com - Dec 12, 2018

Good service and good food, very clean - just very hard to hear for conversations.

Lisa Kay via google.com - Dec 5, 2018

This place was fine eatin'. We ...

This place was fine eatin'. We had wine and beer. The portions were big enough to split if you wanted. We had steak and it was cooked to perfection. They have beer flights if you want to try the different things from the Tin Mill Brewery. The salads were excellent as well. The waitstaff were all on their game and super friendly and a ... read more

Alan C. via yelp.com - Nov 29, 2018

Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?

Reviews

Follow Us

Navigation

Hours

Contact